The Hobbit, Magic, and the Christian Worldview

A good question was recently asked by Scott Doherty.  He wrote,

“I have a suggestion for you fellows, seeing that once again the Tolkein books are being made into movies. A perennial question among Christians is the tension between truth to be found within good literature and the sometimes otherwise forbidden form of that truth. For example, no magic white or otherwise is permitted by God, but the good guys in the literature use magic. How should Christians reason through this?”

For as long as I can remember, I’ve always loved fantasy.  Countless hours have been spent scribbling images of strange creatures and arcane weapons in worn notebooks (usually to the consternation of my teachers).  Even as an adult, I still very much enjoy the genre of fantasy, not only in its written form, but especially as it exists in games.  Crawling through a dungeon with a torch in hand is still a blast, not to mention hurling a fireball at a mob of orcs.  Here one need only check out the wildly fun and popular game Orcs Must Die! or the vast and expansive world of Skyrim to get a sense of what I’m talking about.

And yet, in spite of all the creativity and fun and excitement, a serious question emerges for the Christian.  It’s the perennial one articulated so clearly in the question quoted above.  How should Christians view the use of magic in literature or fantasy in general?

Over the years, I’ve seriously struggled with this problem, so it isn’t just a matter of theory for me.  I’ve thrown away expensive table-top models, feeling that they crossed a dangerous line in what they represented.  I’ve also stayed away from certain games, or character classes, some of which were painful to relinquish because they were cool and appealing to me.  The strategy card game Magic the Gathering, a true masterpiece in its own right, and a game I loved to play (far too much, I might add), proved too much for my conscience.  I had to give it up, and it was very hard to do.

So, yes, I’ve grown more discerning over the years, not to mention sensitive to the issue at hand.  That being said, I’m confident that what I’m about to articulate will leave some feeling uncomfortable.  There’s a spectrum of convictions, and I land somewhere in the middle on this issue; or maybe a tad left of middle.

So where to start?

The Bible, of course.

If anything is evident, it’s that sorcery and divination and witchcraft are forbidden and evil.  So there’s no question there.  Men and women should not engage in such practices.  But the challenge is how to apply this to the realm of the imaginary.  For example, in the case of The Lord of the Rings, there’s an undeniable element of magic, a kind of sorcery that resembles, to some degree, that which is forbidden.

But isn’t that just it?  Isn’t it imaginary?  Is it really occurring?  Of course not.  In the same way that nobody is really dying throughout the story, no one is really practicing magic.

But does that settle the issue?  Well, no.  A couple things should come to mind.  When a man lusts after a woman, he isn’t committing adultery physically, but he is in his mind.  So imagination matters.

There’s another component as well.  Paul commands, “Abstain from every form [or appearance] of evil” (1 Thess 5:22).  A gamer might argue that he isn’t actually murdering people in the violent video game Grand Theft Auto, but he is so graphically playing out the sin, so emulating the evil, it clearly crosses a line.  Wanting to pretend to shoot hookers is depraved.  In the same way, why would someone want to pretend to consult a medium or study the entrails of an animal to divine the future?

The challenge in all this is how to discern when something goes too far.  Should you let your child wear a pirate hat at Long John Silver’s?  Or what about The Pirates Who Don’t  Do Anything in Veggie Tales?

There are some Christians who take this very seriously and avoid all such “appearances of evil.”  Others don’t think twice about it.

At the end of the day, I’m of the conviction that much of this, so far as the minor examples just mentioned are concerned, is a matter of conscience.[1]  They’re disputable issues and each person should be fully convinced in his own mind (See Romans 14).

Do some find the ill-defined use of magic in The Legend of Zelda objectionable?  I’m sure there are some.  But is drinking a blue potion that allows you to jump higher really a matter of emulating the dark arts?  I don’t think so.  It’s innocuous.  Or what about Mario in Super Mario Brothers?  How does he shoot fireballs?  Through sorcery or by simply touching a flower?  To suggest the former seems absurd to me.

But these are easy examples.  The real question is how to navigate the harder ones?  What about, for example, Tolkien’s or C.S Lewis’ use of magic?  Those are a bit trickier.  And for those I’d just like to make a few observations.

Observation One:

While I’m not a diehard fan following the lore of Middle Earth, and am therefore unable to fact check this, I remember reading an interesting article by Steven D. Greydanus in which he compares and contrasts the works of Lewis and Tolkien to that of Rowling.  He examines how each of the authors handles the issue of magic.  Interestingly, he observes that both Lewis and Tolkien are careful to restrict the use of magic to non-human persons and evil humans.

He writes,

“Tolkien and Lewis relegate the pursuit of magic as a safe and lawful occupation to characters who are not in fact human (despite the human appearance of some, like Tolkien’s Gandalf and Lewis’ Coriakin; whom in fact we are told are, respectively, a semi-incarnate angel and an earthbound star). In Harry Potter’s world, by contrast, while some human beings (called ‘Muggles’) lack the capacity for magic, others, including Harry’s true parents (and of course Harry himself), do not.”

This subtle move on the part of Tolkien and Lewis, if true, demonstrates a certain care and sensitivity toward the issue.  They aren’t trying to subvert God’s Law, even in the realm of the imaginative.

Observation Two:

I’m of the opinion that fantasy can be distinguished from the kind of magic forbidden in Scripture.  Allow me to illustrate.

I’ve long been a fan of AD&D (Advanced Dungeons and Dragons).  For those who aren’t familiar with it, it’s basically a game of imagination.  There’s a DM (Dungeon Master) who creates a world for his friends to run around and quest in.  The rulebook provides players with a dice based system for determining combat, personal skills, character development, etc.  It’s fairly complex.

As many are well aware, AD&D has a bad reputation.  There’s some hype here, but there’s also some truth.  AD&D has a fairly advanced system of magic.  Tons of spells and lots of magic.  While some of the magic could be viewed as rather benign, the game does adopt the language of real sorcery.  There are witches, warlocks, wizards and all the rest.  But it goes further than that.  Not only is the language picked up, but it mirrors it.  For example, there is a spell called divination, and it allows a character to divine the future.

So, yes, AD&D has some features that, for the Christian, should be avoided.

That being said, I can see no reason why a person can’t play around in a “magical” world so long as it doesn’t try to emulate the real sorcery of our world.  Basically, as the DM, I define things differently.  Not only do I avoid any such references to divination or mediums, but I also steer clear of anything that would resemble it.

Let me put some flesh on this.  One of my characters has something called a bag of holding.  It is a small brown bag; perfectly normal in its appearance.  However, it is a “magical” bag.  If you were to drop a brick into it, the bag would weigh no more, nor any less.  Moreover, it can hold items far beyond that of what a normal bag its size could hold.  Pretty handy.  Now is that sorcery?  I don’t think so.  The mechanism by which all such “magical” items work is ill-defined.  It’s just the way the fantasy world works.  Perhaps it’s a strange kind of technology.  Or maybe it’s a matter of different physics.  But it is not a power obtained by tapping into the spiritual realm.  As a DM I want to play this game to the glory of God.  Therefore, I am careful not to act as if there’s a quadrant of my life/imagination where His Word isn’t ultimate.  The Lordship of Christ extends to every square molecule, even pretend ones.           

So in the case of the original question, I wouldn’t want to communicate truth through a forbidden form, unless of course I’m making a point about evil.  Bad guys are often evil wizards after all.  The “magic” of the fantasy world would need to be sufficiently emptied of any earthly connections.

Observation Three:

Life is complex.  And as such, there are a multitude of specific cases that could be presented that would perplex me.  I’m actually wrestling with one at the moment.  I’m a huge fan of the table-top war-game system Warhammer 40,000I love the strategy and hobby element.  However, in the game there are wizard-like people called psykers who can manipulate the powers of the warp (some bizarre force in outer space).  They’re pretty powerful warriors and not a little useful for winning.  Basically, these guys can either provide some kind of defensive benefit to your army (like better armor), or negatively affect your opponent (like reduce their armor), or just blast your opponent (like with something called living lightning.  Imagine a guy shooting a bolt of lightning at a particular unit or tank).

I’m fine with all that.  But what bothers me is that they called one of the charts that you randomly roll powers on divination.  Now in the world of gaming, these terms are thrown around with little care or purpose.  So I know the designers of the game just thought it would sound cool to call it that.  And when you see what those powers do, they’re clearly there to help improve dice rolls.  It isn’t about the “sorcery,” but merely improving your odds.  Nevertheless, it’s called something that is forbidden in Scripture.  And it bugs me.  So should I refuse to play on that particular table of powers or play with the knowledge that it isn’t doing what it is called?

Some Christians would say that it is better, when in doubt, to simply refrain from the questionable activity.  There’s certainly wisdom in this.  But then again, if it’s permissible and you want to do it, then why not do it (assuming it isn’t a stumbling block)?

Here I’m reminded of a truth that should be factored into the equation.  It has to do with discerning between good and evil.  Consider how Paul puts it in one place,

“Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that by testing you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and acceptable and perfect” (Romans 12:2.  See also Philippians 1:9-10; 3:15; Eph 5:10; Col 1:9).

Some of these challenging questions can be more readily discerned through spiritual maturity.  Therefore, a good place to start when confronted with a dilemma or ethical question is prayer and study and counsel.  Actually, it begins long before the particular issue surfaces.  Wisdom is accumulated over time.  Holiness is often a slow and painful process.  Discernment requires time.  So I would say to prepare now for the future.

In the end, I’m comfortable with what Tolkien and Lewis have written.  And I for one have thoroughly enjoyed their works.  On the other hand, while the Harry Potter series is certainly well-written and thoroughly enjoyable in its own right, I couldn’t, as a Christian, have written it with a clear conscience.  I feel it blurred some lines that should not have been blurred.


[1] And yes, I’m begging the question here by calling them “minor examples.”  But it’s my position.

16 Comments

  1. B Hodges Jacobs December 18, 2012 at 8:04 pm #

    Great article, but please adjust your printer friendly access to remove all marginal info and change the type size to readable across the FULL PAGE.
    Thankyou from a ‘golden-ager’.

    • Austin Brown December 18, 2012 at 10:35 pm #

      Thanks, Jacobs. As for your requests, I’m kinda scratching my head. To be perfectly honest, I have no idea how to make those changes 🙂 We use WordPress, so I’m pretty sure the settings are as is. If you know what I need to do, do let me know 🙂

  2. Josh Bright December 19, 2012 at 12:36 am #

    Those are some interesting questions. Here’s some more for you: If it is okay for Lewis and Tolkien to give magic to non-human characters, is it okay to pretend to be a non-human character with magical powers in a game? Also have you ever played Arkham Horror? I played it in college, and it was a really well made and fun game, but it had a darker side to it in the realms of magic and deific monsters that I was wondering if you had any thoughts on.

    • Austin Brown December 19, 2012 at 4:32 pm #

      Hi Josh! What about playing as a non-human character with magical powers? My conscience would bother me if the non-human character’s magical abilities felt dark or resembled the sorcery forbidden in Scripture. People will feel differently about where that line is at, of course. For myself, I don’t think there’s a problem with “magical” items, so long as they retain a fantasy emphasis. But take something like Diablo 3. DId I play as a shaman? No. My conscience squirmed slightly, so I went with the barbarian. Is there a disconnect between my hacking apart creatures with blissful violence and shying away from playing the shaman? Strict logic says so, but the conscience doesn’t always play by the rules of strict logic 🙂

      As for Arkham Horror, no I haven’t played it. My guess is that it would land in the same camp as something like 40K and my struggle with the psychic divination table. But that being said, I don’t think there’s a problem, usually, with playing a game that has a darker side. There’s a limit, of course. I play Tyranids in 40K and munch on humans all game long. Are they bad? Yes. But someone has to control the bad team, right 🙂 Here I’m reminded of WW2 games. Someone plays the German side… and wins at times. Is that wrong? I don’t think so. It’s a game that isn’t trying to make some kind of grand moral point.

    • Dakota November 17, 2016 at 1:10 pm #

      I have no idea if this thread is still active considering this is 2016 but nonetheless,

      I really enjoyed this article. I love Jesus with everything that I am. I follow Christ and I desire for him to have his will and way in my life directed by the word of God through the local church and prayer. I say all of this to preface my views. I love fantasy games and lore. Some of my favorite video games and card games I.e (Magic the Gathering) are magic and fantasy related. I don’t have problem playing with magical characters or features in D&D and other games. I do not have convictions from the Holy Spirit about this. I am fully aware of the dangers of actually practicing magic and sorcery and how it is dishonoring and wicked in the Lords eyes. I understand I am a child of God and I feel strongly that this isn’t a stumbling block to me our my friends ( some believers some none). Are these things inherently evil? I don’t think so but I would like some input from the author or anyone else.

  3. Ken Boyer December 19, 2012 at 7:57 am #

    Thanks for presenting this observation. The topic of magic is tricky; for example, a youth director at a church I used to attend brought in a Christian “magician” (although I think he even advertised himself as an “illusionist”) as part of an evangelical outreach event. A local pastor chastised the church in a local Christian newspaper for inviting a “Christian magician” to perform, since “Christianity and magic don’t mix, folks.” However, there’s a difference between “magic” and “illusionism” (or sleight of hand) that is lost on some people.

    That said, the Bible contains the account of Saul’s visit to the Witch of Endor which, while clearly presented as evil, is described in rather creepy detail. Perhaps the vexing issue with Tolkien and Lewis (who were both adherents to theologies a bit different from mainstream Reformed theology) is that some of the protagonists wield magical or superhuman powers (I, for one, am always amazed by Legolas’ aim and inexhaustible supply of arrows, at least as presented in the movies). But, as you point out, these individuals are not human, either, whereas in the Potter series, certain humans are gifted with magical powers that include the ability to commit murder with a curse. What I like about Tolkien’s work is that, while he doesn’t discuss it explicitly, there is always the notion that some (Divine?) Providence is making events come together for good, and the powers and talents of various individuals contribute only small pieces of the much larger puzzle.

    One could ask the same questions about writing books where protagonists commit serious and very destructive sins, but one need look no further than Bible heroes like Abraham and David to see liars and adulterers. If you’re writing with the right motives, what you truly believe will become apparent in your writings, and the wisdom of Romans 12:2 should always be restraining your pen. For that matter, if you have concerns, present your work to the session of your church to see what they think. (As I recall, that practice was something that impressed me about recording artist Michael Card.)

    Again, thanks for sharing some good food for thought!

  4. joanneeddy December 19, 2012 at 8:25 am #

    I am Christian, the wife of a pastor, love Tolkien and CS Lewis, and have written a fantasy book, as yet unpublished, so I have looked at this issue in my own writing. Though I know only a little about gaming, I would like to add a couple of thoughts for consideration as questions when deciding about fantasy. First: Who is the author? Second: What is the author’s purpose or intent?

    For Tolkien and Lewis the first question is easy. Both were friends, and Christians. In fact Tolkien convinced Lewis, who had been agnostic, to become a believer. This gives both a moral compass for their writing. Christianity permeates Lewis’ fantasy work and is the subject of his non-fiction. Both men met regularly to share their writing with each other, no doubt monitoring that they didn’t cross any lines.

    Question 2 is easy to discern for Lewis. His fantasy is fairly apparent Christian allegory. Aslan is a Christ figure and a great way to teach about God, which is the clear intent of all his writing, fiction and non-fiction. Tolkien’s work is more subtle and complex. But nonetheless the allegory is there. I like the complexity because we humans are complex, as is evil. The struggle for us to embrace good amid the temptations of evil, the struggle with asserting authority and power for good and not being corrupted by them, are important themes for Tolkien and for us. And finally that even the small and less grand, have burdens to carry and a role to play in fighting evil, can speak to everyone. Just a few, but Christian messages underly many themes in The Lord of the Rings. Very worth while in my opinion for Christians to read.

    In my own work, which is an epic fantasy (like LOTR) but historical fiction as well, the fantasy comes from the forklore of the time. So some characters seek to learn if they have a special ‘magical’ characteristic. But the real question is will they use it for good or evil. Thus it serves as a way for us to look at our God given gifts and how we use them as well. So that is my intent, at least at the heart of it, and how I stay true to my faith.

  5. Clay December 19, 2012 at 3:47 pm #

    Thank you for your very thought provoking article. I too love fantasy and have struggled with how to handle it with my family.

  6. Alan Dueck December 20, 2012 at 6:47 am #

    Dear Brother,
    I appreciated your articulating your struggle with this matter. I think you’ve answered your own question with these words:

    “At the end of the day, I’m of the conviction that much of this, so far as the minor examples just mentioned are concerned, is a matter of conscience.[1] They’re disputable issues and each person should be fully convinced in his own mind (See Romans 14).”

    You went on to say: “Some of these challenging questions can be more readily discerned through spiritual maturity. Therefore, a good place to start when confronted with a dilemma or ethical question is prayer and study and counsel.”

    You started with God’s word, as you should. Now, through “prayer and study and counsel” you must seek to apply it to your particular circumstances and come to conviction of conscience. As each of us does this, we must remember that we will give account to God.

    One further thought from Scripture. Consider Paul’s words in 1 Cor. 13:11. “When I was a child, I spoke like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I gave up childish ways.” Meaning no disrespect at all, maybe it is about time to put away the childish things, and move on the things of a man.

    May the Lord bless you as you grow in holiness!

  7. Gypsy Blaze August 16, 2013 at 6:05 pm #

    Ll I have experienced a leading of the Holy Spirit (within me) to completely avoid these rpg’s like the plague. They are sin and the Lord is in no part of them. There can be no compromising here. Satan wants to get us hooked, playing these games. Simply putting the evil element of magic into something innocent like a “game” and getting Christians to play and justify it

    • Betti October 12, 2013 at 8:28 pm #

      Amen! The bible says to run from the very presence of evil. These movies represent evil.

  8. John Borgman October 7, 2013 at 8:00 pm #

    I read your article, I haven’t read all the comments, but I would pray and urge you to pray more about games like D&D and Diablo3 which you are still playing. Even though you’re not specifically playing “bad” character calsses within the game, you’re playing a game that glorifies magic/sorcery.

    I have struggled with similiar things myself and it is simply unjustifiable in the face of the truth. I don’t think God has a gray area when it comes to this. The bible says that these things are an abomination to the Lord, so please ask yourself, do you want to play any game that glorifies something which the Lord sees as a detestable abomination?

  9. Chris D November 7, 2015 at 1:07 pm #

    I too have struggled with these areas, trying to justify over and over that it must be fine, its just imagination. I have to agree with Joanneeddy, because what she wrote most closely relates to where I’ve gotten in my seeking of understanding through many prayers.

    One verse that no-one has referenced is probably the most pertinent to this whole issue.

    1 Timothy 4:7 – But refuse and avoid irreverent legends (profane and impure and godless fictions, mere grandmothers’ tales) and silly myths, and express your disapproval of them. Train yourself towards Godliness (piety), [keeping yourself spiritually fit].

    When I read, and reread this verse in the ESV/NIV/KJV versions, I found it hard to understand. Then I went to the amplified version as you see above, and I got the whole meaning from the verse.

    Its speaking to myths, fiction and imagined things that PROFANE God’s name/image, or anything which is in itself Godless. Now if it is that CS. Lewis and Tolkien were writing their pieces as allegories to the life of a Christian, with God at the centre of their stories,however subtly, then there is no way they this can be a Godless myth.

    I’ve actually prayed about this for a long time, and this is the answer I’ve gotten today. I hope that whoever reads this seeks out Gods answer for them as well, rather than just taking everything they read as gospel. Start with the bible and move forward.

  10. Leah November 28, 2015 at 5:27 am #

    Hello! Glad that I stumbled upon this article of yours. I also love Lewis and Tolkien in fact I have since LOTR trilogy and have watch Lewis Chronicles of Narnia British TV movie, and the Hollywood version, I also have the book and the guide book. I have also seen D&D. And I kinda like it since I’m also a gameboard geek, MTG player, and cosplayer.

    You have your point there. And, I also think that we can use these as means of evangelism to others. Everything in this world is owned by God. Unbelievers who watch this, we can share with them the deeper message beyond these works.

    As with others here Im also struggling over these things… but I tell to myself its just a work of fiction and fantasy.
    With regards to horror movies which I like before ( I can see that it doesn’t do me any good but get scared) so I refrain from watching it now. With these fantasy games I can see that the good wins over evil.. and they’re fighting evil. I guess we should see the moral of the story and the lesson also. I know R.C. Sproul also has a story book for kids called the Prince’s Poison Cup, this method of story telling is also an effective way of getting the kids understand the bible story, because at times they lose their interest.

    Pray and discern as always, and ask the Holy Spirit’s for wisdom and guidance.

    Soli Deo Gloria!~

  11. Jane May 11, 2016 at 2:56 am #

    I have a problem with fantasy in general and it is this: if God reveals himself through Jesus and Creation, reality, the world we live in now, with its natural laws and its angels and everything that is mentioned in the Bible, shouldn’t we be grappling with that and not a man made construct. If God went to all the trouble of designing the world, who are we to ‘make’ and revel in different ones? How will that bring us closer to Him? Where are we told to instruct our children about God by using a parallel world, with magic etc?
    My experience is that those who have no knowledge of either the gifts of the Spirit or the Occult think it’s ok, by which I mean safe and God doesn’t mind. But look at Acts 19, 2 Cor 6, 1 Thess 5.

Leave a Reply

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.